Skip to content Skip to main menu
WhartonLogo for The Wharton School
  • Faculty
  • Youth Program
  • Undergrad
  • MBA
  • EMBA
  • PhD
  • Exec Ed
  • Wharton Online
  • Alumni
  • Knowledge at Wharton
Search Wharton
Wharton AI & Analytics Initiative
Menu
  • About
    • Leadership Team
    • Advisory Board
    • Faculty
    • Student Advisory Board
    • Contact Us
  • Centers & Labs
    • Computational Social Science for Business
    • Penn Wharton Budget Model
    • Wharton Accountable AI Lab
    • Wharton Forensic Analytics Lab
    • Wharton Healthcare Analytics Lab
    • Wharton Human-AI Research
    • Wharton Neuroscience Initiative
    • Wharton People Analytics
    • Wharton Research Data Services
    • Wharton Sports Analytics and Business Initiative
  • Gen AI Labs
  • Industry
    • Get Involved
    • AI & Analytics Accelerator
    • AI & Analytics Programs for Executives
    • Case Studies and White Papers
    • Corporate Partnership
    • Professional Learning Hub
  • Researchers
    • Get Involved
    • Case Studies and White Papers
    • Funded Research
    • iWRDS Data Catalog
    • Research Opportunities with Corporate Partners
  • Students
    • Get Involved
    • AI & Analytics Accelerator
    • iWRDS Data Catalog
    • On-Demand Learning
    • Recommended For-Credit Courses
    • Student Clubs
    • Technical Assistant Program
    • Wharton Analytics Fellows
    • Wharton Hack-AI-thon
    • Wharton High School Data Science Competition
  • Society
    • Get Involved
    • The Road to Accountable AI
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • AI and the Future of Work Conference
    • Business & Generative AI Workshop
    • Wharton Neuroscience Summit
    • Wharton People Analytics Conference
    • Wharton Sports Business Summit
    • Women in Data Science @ Penn Conference
      • 2025 Women in Data Science @ Penn Conference
      • 2024 Women in Data Science @ Penn Conference
      • 2023 Women in Data Science @ Penn Conference
      • 2022 Women in Data Science @ Penn Conference
      • 2021 Women in Data Science @ Penn Conference
  • News & Stories

Analytics at Wharton

Research Spotlight

Estimating the Effect of YouTube Recommendations with Homa Hosseinmardi

In Analytics at Wharton’s Research Spotlight series, we highlight research by Wharton and Penn faculty, doctoral students, and researchers whose work focuses on innovations and applications of data science, analytics, and artificial intelligence.

This month, we spoke with Homa Hosseinmardi, a research scientist at the University of Pennsylvania’s Computational Social Science Lab, about her recent study, “Causally Estimating the Effect of YouTube’s Recommender System Using Counterfactual Bots.”

What problem is your work addressing?

Whenever problematic behaviors are observed on online platforms like YouTube (such as radicalization), it is generally hard to determine why they’re taking place. Are users or society influencing these behaviors? Is it the algorithm? Or is it a combination of all of these factors? It is extremely difficult to disentangle algorithmic influence from user intentions from what we observe happening on platforms in the real world.

What methods have you used to address this issue, and why?

In my recent study of radicalization on YouTube, I developed a new methodology that combines observation data with designed experiments to disentangle user preference from the recommendation algorithm, making it feasible to causally infer the role of the recommendation algorithm.

Essentially, to help solve this issue, we need to examine how humans might behave in the absence of algorithmic influence. This requires an environment that could only be facilitated by these platforms themselves, so, alternatively, we have to examine what humans’ experience on these platforms would look like if they had no preference or agency themselves. To that end, we have developed what we call “counterfactual bots” to causally estimate the role and influence of algorithmic recommendations on highly partisan content on YouTube. We compared the behavior of bots that replicate real users’ consumption patterns against our “counterfactual” bots, which follow rule-based trajectories, and observed the difference as the contribution of users’ preferences.

Homa Hosseinmardi

Headshot of a person with short dark hair wearing a patterned sweater, smiling slightly, with a blurred background.

Homa Hosseinmardi is a research scientist at the University of Pennsylvania’s Computational Social Science Lab, led by Duncan Watts. Her research centers around holistic and scaled studies of sociotechnical systems, information ecosystems, and online safety, and she is the lead researcher of the Penn Media Accountability Project (PennMAP).

What have you found?

My study of YouTube indicates little evidence for the popular claim that YouTube drives users to consume more radical political content, either left-wing or right-wing. Instead, to help answer the question of what role these platforms play in the radicalization of users, YouTube, like other social platforms, should otherwise be viewed as part of a larger information ecosystem in which conspiracy theories, misinformation, and hyperpartisan content are widely available, easily discovered, and actively sought out. My study was cited in Congress and also generated a lot of attention in the public and research communities regarding the role we play in the outcome of the algorithms that we use.

What would help improve your solution?

My studies have been limited by desktop usage of sociotechnical systems, and we cannot blindly generalize these findings to mobile, for example. Yet, getting real user trajectories from mobile devices is its own new world of challenges, and expanding my proposed methodology to work on mobile is not a straightforward task.

Where can we go to keep up with your work?

If you’d like to learn more and keep up with my work, please visit my GitHub page.

Related Articles

The YouTube Algorithm Isn’t Radicalizing People

Wharton Women in Analytics 2024

March 25, 2024   |   Computational Social Science, Research, Wharton AI & Analytics News Blog
Back To Top
Additional Links
    Wharton AI & Analytics Initiative
    • About
    • Centers & Labs
    • Gen AI Labs
    • Industry
    • Researchers
    • Students
    • Society
    • Events
    • News & Stories
  • Programs
  • Undergraduate
  • MBA
  • EMBA
  • Doctorate
  • Executive Education
  • Wharton Online
  • Locations
  • Philadelphia
  • San Francisco
  • Beijing
  • The Power of Wharton
  • Global Influence
  • Analytics
  • Entrepreneurship & Innovation
  • Featured
  • Give to Wharton
  • Alumni
  • Knowledge@Wharton
  • Recruiters & Corporations
  • Wharton
  • Faculty
  • About Us
  • Research Centers
  • Departments
  • Resources
  • Contact Us
  • News
  • Faculty & Staff
The University of Pennsylvania
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
Support Wharton
©2025 The Wharton School,  The University of Pennsylvania  |  Wharton AI & Analytics Initiative  |  Privacy Policy  |  Report Accessibility Issues and Get Help